New Age group Secret Garden wrote “Heartstrings,” an instrumental song from the duo's first CD, Songs From a Secret Garden. Streisand incorporated the song into her wedding as “I've Dreamed of You,” with lyrics added by singer-songwriter Ann Hampton-Callaway. “The Sunday before Barbra got married, I got inspired to turn it into a wedding song,” Callaway explained. “I knew that sometime this year she and James were planning to tie the knot, so I decided to tell the story from Barbra's perspective. When I faxed the lyric to Barbra's producer that evening, he was very happy with it, and, after a few minor changes, sent it to Barbra. Monday, I learned that Barbra loved the song and that she wanted me to record a demo and send it immediately. Tuesday, I recorded the demo and overnighted it to Barbra's assistant. Apparently, three hours before the wedding, she heard the demo and decided to sing the song along with a song she has already planned to perform by Melissa Manchester and Tom Snow. It was my playing and Irwin Fisch's string arrangement that accompanied Barbra as she sang 'I've Dreamed Of You' to James Brolin. It's a revelation to me how in love Barbra must be to have the courage to be so spontaneous on such a momentous occasion. A friend of mine who spoke to Marvin Hamlisch was told it was an absolutely stunning moment.”
Columbia Records released a CD single of the song (#38K 79211) as the album's first single.
George and Ira Gershwin's classic “Isn't It A Pity?” became Barbra and Jim's favorite song and was used on their wedding day to welcome the newlyweds to their post-wedding celebration under the supervision of Marvin Hamlisch, who announced them as “Mr. and Mrs. Brolin.” Originally included in the Gershwins' 1932 Broadway musical, Pardon My English and previously recorded by Ella Fitzgerald, Michael Feinstein, Johnny Mathis, Mel Torme, and others, the song perfectly described the wedding couple.
“The Island” — Brazilian songwriters Ivan Lins & Vitor Martins wrote "Começar de Novo" (“Once and Again”) in 1979. Alan and Marilyn Bergman wrote the English lyrics. They also wrote new lyrics for Streisand's record of the song on A Love Like Ours. Originally, the song ended with the lyrics “keep your arms around me, love, we're almost there.”
Streisand explained, “In the original lyric, I felt the lovers didn't quite go far enough ... the couple see the island, but never quite arrive there (I'll leave this to your imagination!). So, I asked Marilyn and Alan if they could write a final verse to complete the moment.”
On our little island, Not a soul can hear us
Silently exchanging fantasies and feelings
Endlessly exploring, learning one another
Till the morning finds us
You were made to love me, and I was made to love you
Keep your arms around me, lose yourself completely
Make it last forever
I can see the island, shining there before us
Now we're getting closer, just keep your arms around me
Come, my love, we're there ...