Cafe Pompeii was another stop on Barbra Streisand's promotional tour for her first album. Barbra performed for the tanned, elderly Miami crowd.
Barbra shared the bill at the Eden Roc with Sergio Franchi. The Miami Herald review stated “Miss Streisand is the freshest, most provocative singer to walk into the show business clearing in many years, as anybody knows who has seen her appearances on Johnny Carson's NBC Tonight TV show. Franchi is a lean, strikingly handsome Italian baritone with a voice of unbelievable range and color. He, too, was flushed out of obscurity by television - on Ed Sullivan's CBS show.”
The Herald continued:
“Miss Streisand, a big girl with fey green eyes and the profile of an Egyptian princess of ancient dynasty, is an avante-garde singer. Her hands grope the air, her head rocks back and out comes singing of the most off-beat exciting kind. And songs of content and arrangement miles outside the standard pale.
The one of two standards she belts out are her own tongue-in-cheek versions -- such songs as "Lover, Come Back to Me," "Big Bad Wolf," and "Happy Days Are Here Again" - done with a sort of mad mockery. The "Happy Days" anthem of the New Deal sounds in Miss Streisand's treatment as if it had been a Republican idea.”
Bob Freund wrote in his Ft. Lauderdale News column that Eddie Fisher, Kenny Miller, Joe E. Lewis and Lisa Hall attended opening night of Franchi/Streisand.
Meanwhile, the Miami News' Herb Kelly wrote that “her opening songs were of the intimate room type but when she moved into ‘Cry Me a River,’ ‘Lover Come Back to Me’ and ‘Coloring Book’ she had it made.”
In his book, Truth Be Told: Off the Record about Favorite Guests, Memorable Moments, Funniest Jokes, and a Half Century of Asking Questions, the venerable talk show host Larry King wrote, “I'll never forget when I first met Barbra Streisand. She was relatively unknown and singing at the Eden Roc in Miami Beach. Her manager called me up and said, ‘Nobody's coming. The waiters are standing on the tables applauding, but nobody else is here. Will you put her on the radio?’”
Streisand appeared on Larry King's WPST show, “Miami Undercover,” in March 1963. King said that before her interview she told him, “I know you don't know me. But you are going to know me, Larry King, you are going to know me.”
While performing at the Eden Roc, Streisand was booked to appear on Ed Sullivan's show. Therefore, Cafe Pompeii announced they would close for the night she flew to New York and back, then resume her shows on Monday, March 25th.