Barbra Streisand heard a demo of the song “Any Moment Now” that was recorded by its songwriters Marvin Hamlisch and Carolyn Leigh. “When I heard Marvin and Carolyn singing and speaking the characters’ dialogue,” Streisand said, “it made me think ... why not make a duets album where the spoken word could be woven into the fabric of the arrangements, much like a real Broadway musical?”
In December 2015, Barbra told the Hollywood Reporter, “I love doing my albums because I have a wonderful team that I work with.But there's no ego in it. It's like, I'll say something, they come up with something, and, ‘Oh! Ah! Go to the piano and try this!’ It's like doing a play.”
Walter Afanasieff started making instrumental demos for the songs on Encore in the summer of 2015 with his engineer Tyler Gordon. Over at Momentum Studio, Bill Ross also produced demos with his associate Mary Webster. Shortly after the demo work began, David Reitzas recorded the dialogue for the songs at Grandma's House on Streisand's California property. “That was the early stages of creating a kind of dialogue road-map,” Reitzas explained to Sound On Sound magazine. “She performed all the parts of the female vocals, and Walter or her husband [James Brolin] did the male vocal parts.”
David Reitzas continued: “The process is that I load their demos as audio into Pro Tools. I spend time with these demos, making them sound as good as I can, so we can keep building the songs and figuring out the arrangement while we record vocals [...] once it was decided who was going to sing on a track, we had to work out the keys that are best for the singer or singers, which meant that we might have to replace a whole section in the demo, using a different key and with new transitions to get to that key. The arrangements are constantly evolving, and Walter and Bill later in their studios changed the MIDI to match the changes I made to the audio.”
The next step in the process of creating the Encore album was to start recording the final vocals. Sessions began February 12, 2016 at Woodshed Recording. Many of the promotional videos and interviews for this album were recorded at the craftsman-style studio, situated on a picturesque piece of property in Malibu, California. Jamie Foxx and Streisand recorded “Climb Ev'ry Mountain” first on February 17th. “You cannot tell me that my life is not blessed,” Foxx posted on Instagram. “Just finished doing a record with the legendary @BarbraStreisand.”
“At the Ballet,” “Loving You,” “Pure Imagination,” “Losing My Mind,” and “Who Can I Turn To?” followed.
“We spent a lot of time on the vocals, trying them one day, picking the best ideas, trying them again another day, and so on, until we felt comfortable with the most honest readings,” Reitzas stated.
The virtual duet with Anthony Newley, who died in 1999, was Streisand's idea. “I’ve heard that David Bowie was very influenced by Tony Newley,” Streisand stated. “ I was doing Funny Girl and he was doing The Roar of the Greasepaint, and I met him that year and thought he was fantastic. Then we became friends.”
Newley even wrote a song about Streisand called “Too Much Woman.” When Streisand was reminded about it, she said, “I’m proud of that song. I’m proud that he wrote it for me.”